Differences between version 9 and predecessor to the previous major change of WikiDiscussion.
Other diffs: Previous Revision, Previous Author, or view the Annotated Edit History
| Newer page: | version 9 | Last edited on Saturday, August 28, 2004 11:32:00 am | by CraigBox | Revert |
| Older page: | version 8 | Last edited on Friday, August 27, 2004 3:02:32 pm | by DanielLawson | Revert |
@@ -13,15 +13,15 @@
;StuartYeates: i don't really care, so long as there exist [WikiGnome]s to homogenise the page names it doesn't really matter what set of rules they use.
;PerryLorier: Yes, but the [WikiGnome]s have to agree.
-;CraigBox: Lapsed gnome ([GNOME]?) disagrees. I think that having !BookOfFooReview is extraneous if there is no !BookOfFoo page. I like having stems (!BookReviewBookOfFoo). I don't mind Foo and !FooNotes but given the chance to do everything again I'd want everything to be as Wiki:CamelCase (StudlyCaps) as possible.
+;CraigBox: Lapsed gnome ([GNOME]?) disagrees. I think that having !BookOfFooReview is extraneous if there is no !BookOfFoo page. I like having stems (!BookReviewBookOfFoo). I don't mind Foo and !FooNotes but given the chance to do everything again I'd want everything to be as Wiki:CamelCase (!
StudlyCaps) as possible.
;DanielLawson: Regarding book reviews: We don't have to have them in the wiki at all. They are an exception to our standard system, as Craig points out - there is no !BookOfFoo page. But, I don't think there is a better place to put them, and I don't think we should work on putting more software in place when the wiki does the job. I think we should still adopt a standard, consistent nomenclature (and have it documented somewhere so people can learn what it is), HOWEVER I don't think we should pick one that requires a huge amount of effort to change to - unless someone wants to dedicate however many hours it'll take to fixing it (ie, saying 'all pages should be !PrefixName, eg !NotesOnFoo, or !BookReviewFoo', is going to take a fair amount of work). The most important thing is to be consistent, and IMO we should be consistent with what we have already.
-
+;CraigBox: We were consistent with !BookReviewFoo, and then it was changed. That really pissed me off actually. Why do all the Howto pages start with HowTo?
... Your comments here ...
----
CategoryMeta
